Editorial
The Gist
-
AI doesn’t fix broken CX. It amplifies the flaws already present. If your service is impersonal, AI won’t change that. It will just make the same mistakes faster.
-
Blaming AI missteps. AI is often blamed for robotic customer interactions, but the real issue is poor training, bad implementation and human resistance to AI-driven insights.
-
Bettering CX. AI should enhance CX by improving efficiency and personalization without over-humanizing interactions to the point of artificial awkwardness.
More than ever before, the industry is treating AI as the solution for CX challenges. They’re using it to automate interactions, handle inquiries and personalize at scale. But when AI-driven service misses the mark, companies rush to blame the technology.
AI doesn’t make bad hiring decisions; people do. AI doesn’t create tone-deaf automation; companies program it that way. AI doesn’t ignore churn signals; teams dismiss AI-generated insights.
Instead of asking whether AI in customer experience needs more human qualities, businesses should ask: Are we feeding AI the right data to learn from? Are we applying AI insights or just letting them sit in a dashboard? Are we balancing automation and human intervention effectively?
Poor AI strategy leads to ineffective CX. It magnifies broken processes and disconnects customers from real value.
What else are we doing wrong with AI in customer experience?
Table of Contents
- Mistake 1: Expecting AI to Fix Bad CX
- Mistake 2: Ignoring AI-Driven Insights
- Mistake 3: Over-Humanizing AI to the Point of Ineffectiveness
- Mistake 4: Letting AI Run Without Oversight
- AI Needs a Smarter Human Strategy
- A Summary of Top Mistakes Companies Make With AI in Customer Experience
Mistake 1: Expecting AI to Fix Bad CX
The Wrong Approach: Not Closing CX Loop
The wrong approach in customer experience often results in frustration and missed opportunities. For example, a retail chatbot handles basic inquiries but lacks escalation options, forcing customers into frustrating loops. Similarly, a call center’s AI routes high-value customers based on speed, not issue complexity, which leads to rushed, ineffective resolutions. In another case, a loyalty program automatically pushes discounts but removes human discretion, so it fails to recognize when a personal outreach would be more valuable.
How to Do It Right: Know Customer Journey Upfront
Companies often layer AI onto broken processes, expecting automation to magically resolve inefficiencies. Instead, fix the process first. Identify where friction exists in the customer journey before deciding what AI should handle and what requires human expertise. AI can even help you create the process.
Next, use AI in customer experience as an efficiency booster, not a relationship substitute. AI should automate redundant tasks, such as verifying customer information and retrieving order histories. Agents should spend more time resolving complex issues.
Finally, design AI escalation paths. AI-driven support should be seamless, not siloed. When AI identifies frustration signals, customers should be transferred to an agent without repeating information.
Related Article: What Causes Customer Rage Today?
Mistake 2: Ignoring AI-Driven Insights
The Wrong Approach: Assuming Humans Are Superior to AI in CX Insights
Ignoring AI insights can undermine both customer trust and business success. Here are some examples. AI flags a high-value customer at risk of churning, but a frontline agent dismisses the alert and assumes their judgment is superior. Or a company’s AI detects recurring loyalty program complaints, but leadership disregards the data as a small anomaly. Alternatively, AI recognizes customer sentiment shifts, but the company fails to act on these insights, making "we’re sorry" emails feel hollow.
How to Do It Right: Investigate All AI in CX Red Flags
AI in customer experience provides incredibly valuable insights, but only if companies actually use them. It’s important to trust AI predictions but also verify them with human logic. If AI detects churn risk, teams should investigate the cause and engage the customer accordingly. Also, don’t forget to close the feedback loop. AI-generated insights shouldn’t sit untouched in reports; they should directly inform CX strategy, marketing efforts and agent training. Finally, turn AI insights into action. If AI consistently flags the same pain points, don’t just tweak responses. Fix the root issue.
Bi-weekly CX reviews should incorporate AI-driven data to proactively adjust customer strategies before problems escalate. In the early stages of AI integration, daily audits may be necessary to make sure AI-driven decisions align with actual customer needs and company intentions.
Mistake 3: Over-Humanizing AI to the Point of Ineffectiveness
The Wrong Approach: Making AI Too Human-ey
Over-humanizing AI can lead to unwanted results. For example, an AI chatbot is programmed to mimic human banter, but that only results in off-putting, overly chatty interactions when customers just want answers. Or AI over-personalizes recommendations, and that makes customers feel watched rather than understood. Alternatively, a self-service AI may try to sound "empathetic" in an urgent support situation, but that slows down resolutions instead of providing a direct solution.
How to Do It Right: Balance Engagement and Efficiency With AI in CX
AI in customer experience should embody brand tone, but forcing AI to act too human can backfire. Don’t make AI overly conversational when speed is the priority. A chatbot should be warm and on-brand but direct when urgency is needed. Also, strike the right balance between engagement and efficiency. Customers appreciate personalization, but they also want clear, effective service.
Make sure AI interactions mirror real-world service excellence. A high-end hotel doesn’t ask excessive questions before helping a guest; it anticipates needs and gets to the point when necessary. AI should do the same.
Instead of forcing AI to “sound human,” it should focus on being helpful, responsive and aligned with exceeding customer expectations.
Related Article: The Hidden Dangers of Over-Personalization in Marketing
Mistake 4: Letting AI Run Without Oversight
The Wrong Approach: Bad Customer Data in, Bad Customer Experience out
Not using proper oversight over AI means it won’t result in the ideal circumstances. For example, AI personalizes offers based on outdated customer data, making recommendations irrelevant. Or a predictive chatbot continues suggesting the wrong solutions, ultimately frustrating users rather than assisting them. Or maybe AI-powered pricing adjusts dynamically, but without human calibration, it unintentionally overcharges customers.
How to Do It Right: Testing AI Against Real Customer Interactions
AI in customer experience is not "set and forget." It needs ongoing calibration to remain effective. Monitor AI logic bi-weekly, more frequently in early implementation. AI should be regularly reviewed to make sure it’s making accurate, customer-friendly decisions. Also, test AI against real customer interactions. AI models should be exposed to live customer data, then adjusted to reflect real-world behavior. This could be for data, tone or process.
And don’t forget to build a cross-functional AI oversight team. AI decisions shouldn’t live in silos. Customer service, marketing and CX teams should align on AI-driven strategies.
Even the best AI deteriorates without proper oversight. Keeping AI sharp requires active tuning, testing and customer feedback integration.
AI Needs a Smarter Human Strategy
Companies that succeed with AI don’t just install it and hope for the best. They also train AI using real-world CX expertise; AI in customer experience is only as good as the quality of training it receives.
In addition, they use AI to enhance human performance, not replace it. AI should streamline CX operations so humans can focus on high-value interactions.
Finally, successful companies continuously refine AI based on live data. AI must evolve alongside customer behaviors, preferences and service expectations.
Webinar
Sep
25
CMS Briefing: A Live Look at What’s Next in AI-Driven Platforms
Learn how leading organizations are using AI‑driven tools to publish faster, personalize smarter and stay secure.
Register
Webinar
On demand
Ready or Not: How Data-First Organizations Are Unlocking Agentforce Potential
Learn how to cut through the noise, activate Agentforce and build a Salesforce AI strategy that actually delivers.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
AI in Customer Service: Faster Resolutions, Happier Customers
Don’t let rising demand burn out your team. See how to build a smarter, more resilient support org.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
From Hype to High-Impact CX Strategies That Actually Scale
Turn buzzworthy AI and outsourcing trends into measurable CX wins with fresh 2025 data.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
Insights to Action Rethinking the Contact Center for Real Business Impact
Join our exclusive webinar to hear CX executives share their innovative strategies for transforming service delivery.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
Accelerating Healthcare Ops with AI
Sign up to see how your peers are putting AI to work — and making it stick.
Watch Now
The biggest mistake in AI-driven CX isn’t AI itself. It’s assuming that AI works without a strategy. To make AI work, start with better human leadership, smarter data and a commitment to continuous optimization.
A Summary of Top Mistakes Companies Make With AI in Customer Experience
Editor's note: AI can enhance customer experience—but only if applied strategically. Many companies fall into avoidable traps that undermine its potential. The table below summarizes the author's key missteps and what CX leaders should be doing instead.
| Mistake | What It Looks Like | How to Do It Right |
|---|---|---|
| Expecting AI to Fix Bad CX | Layering AI onto broken processes and expecting it to resolve systemic issues without human strategy. | Fix the journey first, then automate. Use AI to reduce effort, not replace empathy. Build seamless escalation paths. |
| Ignoring AI-Driven Insights | Dismissing churn alerts, sentiment signals or loyalty feedback flagged by AI. | Investigate all AI red flags. Incorporate insights into CX strategy and take visible action to close the loop. |
| Over-Humanizing AI | Programming bots to sound overly chatty or empathetic in situations that demand speed and clarity. | Prioritize helpfulness over human mimicry. Match tone to the context. Efficiency should never be sacrificed for charm. |
| Letting AI Run Without Oversight | Outdated inputs, unchecked personalization and misaligned responses due to lack of monitoring. | Regularly test and tune AI models. Involve cross-functional teams and expose AI to live feedback loops. |
Learn how you can join our contributor community.
